Top Picks
Dark in Love Vintage Striped Ruffle Tier Dress
CHLOE’S PICK CRONJAGERDark in Love Vintage Striped Ruffle Tier Dress
$55.99 CRONJAGER
Banned Apparel Elysia Dress
MEGAN’S PICK CRONJAGERBanned Apparel Elysia Dress
$42.00 CRONJAGER
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Buckle Strap Round Toe Mary Jane Flats Shoes - brown / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
HANNAH’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Buckle Strap Round Toe Mary Jane Flats Shoes - brown / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
$103.00 TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Women's Pointed Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Slip On Buckle Mid Chunky Heel Mary Janes Pumps - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
IMOGEN’S PICK TINACUSTOMTinaCus Women's Pointed Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Slip On Buckle Mid Chunky Heel Mary Janes Pumps - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
$102.40 TINACUSTOM
Black Leather Pointy Heels
ESME’S PICK ZAPAKA VINTAGE, INC.Black Leather Pointy Heels
$54.00 ZAPAKA VINTAGE, INC.
How we pick

These picks came from Chloe, Megan, Hannah, Imogen and Esme, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $506 pieces
$50 to $1005 pieces
Worth the splurge4 pieces