It clicked for me on a Tuesday when I'd swapped my usual tote for a backpack because my shoulder was wrecked from carrying everything on one side for about three years straight, and I turned up to work with both hands free, phone in one pocket, keys in another, nothing digging into my collarbone. Felt like I'd been doing bags wrong the whole time.
Before you buy, actually open the thing up and check what's going on inside, because that's where a lot of these fall apart. Look for a zip that goes all the way round rather than one of those half moon openings that looks lovely on the hanger and is a nightmare when you're rooting for your purse on a moving bus. Check the straps adjust properly and sit flat rather than twisting, and have a feel of the back panel, because if there's no padding there you'll know about it after an hour of a heavy charger and a water bottle pressing into your spine. Canvas is lovely and light and softens with wear but it marks if you set it down on a wet pavement, nylon is the one that shrugs off weather and doesn't crease into that saggy shape, and leather looks the part but it's heavier before you've even put anything in it, so factor that in if you're already carrying a laptop.
On colour, black is the easy one, obviously, goes with everything and hides scuffs at the bottom where keys live, but I've got a lot of time for a proper tan or a deep olive too, because they don't show the grubby patches that build up on the straps the way a pale grey does within about a month. Pale colours look gorgeous in a shop and genuinely stressful once you've had it near a coffee cup, so unless you're the sort of person who never puts a bag down on the floor, I'd leave the cream version to someone braver than me. If you've never owned a backpack before, start with something mid sized in a fabric you can wipe down, not the huge hiking style one and not the tiny fashion one that holds a lipstick and nothing else, because the middle size is the one that actually earns a place by the door and gets used every single day rather than sitting in the cupboard looking at you.
The one mistake, and I did this myself, is buying one with no pocket for your phone and keys separate from the main bit, so you end up digging through a charger, a brush and half a packet of mints every time someone tries to pay you back for coffee.