You can spot a good watch from the other side of a room the way you can spot a good coat. A cheap one sits high and shiny on the wrist, the strap stiff as a ruler, the face a bit too bright, like it's trying to get your attention before you've even asked the time. A good one just sits there, quiet, a bit heavier than you expect, and somehow makes the hand look finished rather than decorated. I had a leather strapped one years ago that creased within a fortnight and went the colour of a teabag by the summer, and I wore it anyway out of stubbornness, which tells you everything about my twenties.
What actually separates the two is mostly in places you don't look at first. The strap matters more than the face, I think, whether it's a proper leather that softens with wear or a stainless link that sits flat without pinching the skin, because a cheap bracelet strap will catch arm hair at the worst possible moment, every single time. The clasp should close with a proper click, not a flimsy fold that pops open on a bus. Check the glass too, a sapphire or mineral crystal won't scratch the first time it meets a worktop or a car key, where the thin plastic ones on bargain watches cloud over within a year. A well finished case has a weight to it, nothing rattles, the second hand sweeps rather than jerks, and the back doesn't have a seam you can catch a nail on. For everyday wear, a plainer metal or leather watch earns its place through autumn and winter under cuffs and coat sleeves, while a lighter strap, fabric or a pale leather, feels right once the weather turns and arms are bare again. It moves from desk to dinner without anyone clocking the switch, which is the whole point of the thing.
Before you buy, try it on and let your wrist hang the way it actually hangs, not held up for inspection, and see if the face sits where you want it rather than slipping round to the underside. Check the weight against your own wrist bones, too heavy and it'll bruise over a long day. Have a proper look at the stitching on a leather strap and the finish where the links meet the clasp, that's where the cheap ones show themselves first. If you're starting from nothing, go for a simple metal bracelet watch with a plain face, no fuss, nothing you'll tire of by March. It'll sit under a jumper sleeve on a Tuesday and look right with the one good dress you already own, without you having to think about it twice.