Top Picks
10k Tri Color Tri-Color Black Hills Gold Rose in Heart Necklace
SIOBHAN’S PICK GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.10k Tri Color Tri-Color Black Hills Gold Rose in Heart Necklace
$368.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver Rhodium-Plated 7-8mm Black Fwc Pearl Drop Heart Necklace
GEMMA’S PICK GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.Sterling Silver Rhodium-Plated 7-8mm Black Fwc Pearl Drop Heart Necklace
$162.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Heart and Sun Buckle Leather Metal Spliced Choker
AISHA’S PICK BLACKHEAD JEWELRYHeart and Sun Buckle Leather Metal Spliced Choker
$129.00 BLACKHEAD JEWELRY
MUKTANK x Mandarin Zan Club Swimming Dragon in the Abyss Black Pearl Necklace
MAGGIE’S PICK MUKZINMUKTANK x Mandarin Zan Club Swimming Dragon in the Abyss Black Pearl Necklace
$169.00 MUKZIN
Sterling Silver Sentimental Expressions Rhodium-Plated Antiqued Black Paw In Heart Ash Holder 18 Inch Necklace
CHLOE’S PICK GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.Sterling Silver Sentimental Expressions Rhodium-Plated Antiqued Black Paw In Heart Ash Holder 18 Inch Necklace
$112.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
How we pick

These picks came from Siobhan, Gemma, Aisha, Maggie and Chloe, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $506 pieces
$50 to $1004 pieces
Worth the splurge15 pieces
10k Tri Color Tri-Color Black Hills Gold Rose in Heart Necklace
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

10k Tri Color Tri-Color Black Hills Gold Rose in Heart Necklace

$368.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver White Night Rhodium-Plated Black And Diamond Heart 18 Inch Necklace With 2 Extender
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver White Night Rhodium-Plated Black And Diamond Heart 18 Inch Necklace With 2 Extender

$395.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver Sentimental Expressions Rhodium-Plated Mother A Part Of My Heart 18 Inch Necklace
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver Sentimental Expressions Rhodium-Plated Mother A Part Of My Heart 18 Inch Necklace

$118.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver White Night Rhodium-Plated Black And Diamond Triple Heart 18 Inch Necklace With 2 Extender
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver White Night Rhodium-Plated Black And Diamond Triple Heart 18 Inch Necklace With 2 Extender

$250.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Heart and Sun Buckle Leather Metal Spliced Choker
BLACKHEAD JEWELRY

Heart and Sun Buckle Leather Metal Spliced Choker

$129.00 BLACKHEAD JEWELRY
MUKTANK X JUUNNGLE NANAX Caramel Heart Necklace
MUKZIN

MUKTANK X JUUNNGLE NANAX Caramel Heart Necklace

$139.00 MUKZIN
MUKTANKĂ—SUN HUNTER Black and White Faux Pearl Versatile Wear Necklace
MUKZIN

MUKTANKĂ—SUN HUNTER Black and White Faux Pearl Versatile Wear Necklace

$109.00 MUKZIN
MUKTANK x Mandarin Zan Club Swimming Dragon in the Abyss Black Pearl Necklace
MUKZIN

MUKTANK x Mandarin Zan Club Swimming Dragon in the Abyss Black Pearl Necklace

$169.00 MUKZIN
Sterling Silver White Night Rhodium-Plated Black And Diamond Heart Key 18 Inch Necklace With 2 Extender
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver White Night Rhodium-Plated Black And Diamond Heart Key 18 Inch Necklace With 2 Extender

$299.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver Sentimental Expressions Gold-Plated Grandma 18In Heart Necklace
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver Sentimental Expressions Gold-Plated Grandma 18In Heart Necklace

$152.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver Brilliant Embers Rhodium Plated 150 Stone 18 Inch Micro Pav‚Äö Black And White Cz Heart Necklace With 2 Extender
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver Brilliant Embers Rhodium Plated 150 Stone 18 Inch Micro Pav‚Äö Black And White Cz Heart Necklace With 2 Extender

$114.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver Landstrom'S Mt. Rushmore Black Hills 12K Gold Accents Lab Created White Opal Heart 18 Inch Spring Ring Clasp Necklace
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver Landstrom'S Mt. Rushmore Black Hills 12K Gold Accents Lab Created White Opal Heart 18 Inch Spring Ring Clasp Necklace

$123.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver Sentimental Expressions Rhodium-Plated Antiqued Black Paw In Heart Ash Holder 18 Inch Necklace
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver Sentimental Expressions Rhodium-Plated Antiqued Black Paw In Heart Ash Holder 18 Inch Necklace

$112.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Sterling Silver Rhodium-Plated 7-8mm Black Fwc Pearl Drop Heart Necklace
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Sterling Silver Rhodium-Plated 7-8mm Black Fwc Pearl Drop Heart Necklace

$162.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.
Titanium/Silver Two Tone Titanium/Ster.Sil Black Ti Polished Etched Heart 2 Chain Necklace
GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.

Titanium/Silver Two Tone Titanium/Ster.Sil Black Ti Polished Etched Heart 2 Chain Necklace

$143.99 GOLDIA.COM L.L.C.