The thing that catches people out with autumn boots is thinking one pair will cover everything, then standing at the bus stop in October wishing you'd bought boots for the weather instead of boots for the outfit. The transitional months are the hardest to dress for, not the depths of winter, because the ground's wet but it's not cold enough for proper lined boots, and the light's still decent enough that you want to look like you tried. It's worth sorting out early though, because once you've got the right pairing of boot and outfit sorted, autumn stops being a wardrobe problem and starts being the easiest stretch of the year to dress for.
If you've got nothing suitable yet, start with an ankle boot in a flat or low block heel, in brown or black leather or a good leather look, nothing too polished or too rugged. That's the one that goes under jeans, under a midi skirt, under tights with a dress, without you having to think about it twice. Check the sole flexes slightly when you bend it in your hand, a completely rigid sole means a stiff walk and sore feet by the second wear. Press the inside of the ankle too, you want some structure there or it'll collapse after a few weeks of actual walking. Once that pair's earning its keep, a knee high or a chunkier lug sole boot becomes the thing you add for the days that need more warmth or more attitude, rather than your only option.
These suit everything from a school run to an evening out once you change the top half, and they come into their own from late September through to the point it turns properly icy, when you might want something with more grip underfoot. For an ordinary wardrobe, boots like this want to sit against a decent pair of straight leg or slightly flared jeans so the hem skims the top rather than bunching, a midi skirt in a heavier fabric that won't blow about, and a jumper long enough to half cover the waistband. Tights under a dress with an ankle boot over the top is a reliable combination for anything from coffee to dinner. A longer coat balances a chunkier boot nicely, while a cropped jacket works better with something slimmer at the ankle.
This kind of boot and outfit pairing suits anyone who wants to get dressed in fifteen minutes flat on a grey morning and still feel like they made an effort.