The bit of the year when this comes into its own is that stretch from the end of September through October, when it's too cold for bare legs and too warm for a proper coat, and you stand in front of the open wardrobe at 7am having a small crisis about what counts as dressed. That's when a handful of decent layers, a good knit, trousers that actually fit, earn whatever you paid for them.
The pieces that are worth having are the ones that still look like something after six weeks of actual wear, not the first photo on a hanger. Knitwear is the big tell here. A cheap jumper pills under the arms within a fortnight and goes bobbly across the chest where a bag strap sits, while a better one keeps its shape wash after wash if you turn it inside out, use a cool cycle and never, ever tumble dry it, because that's how a size 20 jumper becomes a child's jumper in forty minutes. Cords and heavier trousers age better than you'd expect, they soften rather than wear thin, though the knees will eventually give you away if you kneel on them a lot. Fit is where most of this falls apart, and not because the sizing's wrong exactly, more that a lot of autumn ranges are cut for a straight body with curve added as an afterthought, so you get trousers that fit the waist and gape at the hip, or a jacket with sleeves that look generous until you actually bend your arm. Order your usual size first, but check the sleeve and the rise before you check anything else, those are the two places that give the game away.
None of it is right for everything. A capsule built for layering is no good if your week is mostly one extreme temperature or another, an overheated office or a freezing warehouse, and no amount of good knitwear fixes a coat that's too thin for the actual cold snap in November. It's also not the place to spend your whole budget on trend colours, because autumn capsules live or die on how well the pieces mix with each other, not how striking any one piece is alone. Stick to the colours that don't argue with anything else you own: rust, a proper chocolate brown, bottle green, a soft grey that isn't quite black. Those four will sit next to almost anything already in your wardrobe without a fight.
Build even two or three of these right and that one dress you've had for years suddenly has somewhere to go on a Tuesday in October.