Hold one up before you buy it and check where the strap sits when it's done up, not just how cute the hardware looks. A belt bag that rides up near your ribs because the strap's too short is going to annoy you by the second wear, and you will not fix that with a safety pin, I have tried.
Sizing on these is really about the strap length more than the bag itself, so look for one with a decent extra hole or two, or better, a fully adjustable buckle rather than fixed notches. If you're carrying it across the body rather than round the waist, you want it sitting just above your hip, not squeezing your middle like a cummerbund. Leather and leather look alternatives hold their shape and don't sag when you overstuff them, which you will, because a phone, keys, lip balm and a bank card somehow weigh the same as a house brick by the end of the day. Soft nylon versions are lighter and brilliant for anything active, but they go baggy fast and the zip pulls can snag on jumpers, so check the finish on the zip before you commit. Watch the pockets too. A lot of them have one big compartment and nothing else, so your phone ends up scratched against your keys within a week.
Where this bag falls apart is anywhere you need to carry more than the absolute basics. Day trip with a water bottle and a cardigan, no chance. Anything that needs a laptop or even a decent paperback, forget it, you'll be holding the overflow in your hand anyway, which defeats the point of a hands free bag. It also doesn't love a very fitted dress, because the strap cuts across the one bit of structure the dress was relying on, and you end up with a visible line you didn't ask for. Worn over a long flowing coat it disappears completely and you'll spend the whole day patting yourself down convinced you've lost it. Where it genuinely works is with jeans and a plain top, a jumpsuit, anything with a waist or a simple silhouette it can sit against without a fight. Trainers suit it better than heels somehow, I couldn't tell you why.
Wipe leather ones down with a damp cloth rather than letting hand cream and bag straps get acquainted for months before you notice the marks.