For years I avoided a black bag on the basis that it was boring, the kind of thing you buy when you've stopped trying. What changed my mind was a week where I carried a burgundy tote to three separate things it didn't match, and realised I'd spent more energy thinking about the bag than wearing it. Black stops that conversation before it starts.
It earns its space most obviously at work, where it needs to sit next to a blazer without arguing with it, but the real test is how much else it covers. It's the bag for a parents' evening straight after work, for a funeral you find out about on a Tuesday, for the bit of winter where every coat you own is some shade of navy or camel and a bag in any other colour just adds noise. Summer is where it struggles a bit, next to linen and pale colours it can look heavier than it needs to, so if you're buying for July don't expect the same ease you'd get in November.
If you've got none, start with a cross body in a structured shape rather than a slouchy one. A structured bag holds its line whether it's half empty on a Monday or stuffed with a cardigan and a second pair of shoes by Friday, and that consistency is worth more than the extra style points a soft, floppy version gives you on day one. Leather is still the easiest material to live with long term, it takes a scuff and just looks like it's been used rather than damaged, whereas a cheap PU will crack at the corners within a year and tell on itself every time. A coated canvas is a decent middle ground if budget is tight and you're hard on bags.
On finish, the matte ones are more forgiving day to day, they don't show fingerprints or rain spots the way a patent or high shine black does, and they go from desk to evening without looking like they're trying too hard either way. Hardware matters more than people admit. Gold fittings warm the whole bag up and are more forgiving against most skin tones, silver can look a bit cold and corporate on its own but sits well against grey and denim. The detail that makes a good black bag a genuine pleasure is a lining in a colour you can actually see, because fishing for keys in a black bag with a black lining, in a dimly lit car park, at the end of a long day, is its own small misery.