There's a point in most mornings when you've got thirty seconds to swap bags and no patience for digging about, and that's when a box bag earns its spot by the door. You put the essentials in once, you shut the clasp, and that's the decision made for the day. No rummaging at the bottom for your card, because there isn't really a bottom to speak of, just a shape that holds what it holds and nothing more.
The fit problem with these isn't on your body, it's inside the bag itself, so think about capacity before anything else. A lot of box bags look generous in a photo and then turn out to hold a phone, a lipstick and not much else, which is fine until you need your keys and a water bottle too. Hold it against what you actually carry on a normal day before you decide, and check the depth as well as the width, because a shallow box bag with a wide base can still leave your purse sticking out the top. The strap length matters more than people assume too, a short handle that sits in your hand is a different bag entirely from one on a longer strap that crosses the body, and you want to know which one you're getting before you've paid for it.
If you've never owned one, start with a structured style in a neutral colour and a cross body strap, not a tiny handheld one. The cross body version does more for you day to day, and a shape that holds its own without being stuffed full looks better in low light than a soft slouchy bag ever will. Save the top handle, ladylike version for later, once you know whether the rigid shape actually suits how you move through a day.
It sits well against plain, uncluttered outfits, which is most of what's already in your wardrobe if you're honest. A simple coat, a jumper and trousers, nothing with too much going on, because the bag itself is the detail and it gets lost against a busy print. It also looks sharper against softer fabrics than against other structured pieces, so a straight blazer and a stiff bag together can end up looking like you're carrying two separate ideas.
In the shop, check the clasp before anything else, because that's the part that wears first and the part you'll use fifty times a week. Open and shut it a few times, feel for stiffness or a cheap click. Check the corners too, cheap box bags soften and dent along the edges after a few months of being set down on tables and floors, while a better made one keeps its shape after a full year of being thrown into bags, cars and under cafe chairs.
Put it on the arm of a coat you already wear too often and it stops looking too often.
Quilted bags sit nicely alongside these.