Cream bags earn their moment the second the coats get lighter and the evenings stretch out, those first warm weekends when everything in your wardrobe suddenly looks heavy and dark against the weather. They turn up again properly for wedding season, for the stretch between May and September when you want something that reads as put together without matching anything too hard, and they sit well with the kind of outfit that's otherwise all neutrals and you need one piece that looks deliberate rather than default.
The honest bit is that cream ages, and it ages visibly, which is either the charm or the problem depending on how precious you are. A good leather one will take on a patina that looks lived in rather than grubby, especially on the corners and the base, but a coated canvas version just gets grey at the edges and stays grey, no amount of baby wipes brings that back. Keep a proper leather balm or a cream specific cleaner in the house rather than reaching for whatever's under the sink, and wipe the handles after a few wears because that's where hand cream and foundation go first and it shows fastest on pale leather. Dark denim is the real enemy here, not aesthetically but literally, the dye transfers onto cream straps in warm weather and it does not come out, so new raw jeans and a cream bag together for a whole day is asking for a problem you'll be scrubbing at later. It also clashes more than you'd expect with anything stark white, two different whites sitting next to each other on an outfit just look like a mismatch rather than a colour story, even though in your head they're the same family.
It's the wrong choice for anyone doing a daily commute through rain, through prams, through a bag that gets dumped on pub floors and train platforms, because cream shows every splash and every scrape and doesn't have the decency to hide it the way black does. It's also not the one to carry if you're the sort of person whose bag doubles as a bin, loose pens included, because ink on cream leather is close to a write off.
What separates a good one from a disappointing one comes down to the leather itself, whether it's got any body to it or whether it's thin and will crease into permanent lines within a month, plus the stitching on the handles, which should be tight and even rather than loose enough to see daylight through. Hardware matters too, cheap gold plating on a cream bag goes patchy and brassy fast, and that contrast against pale leather is unforgiving. Carried with navy, with washed out denim, with anything olive or camel, it does more for a plain outfit than people give it credit for.
On a similar note, see tote bags.