I spent most of my twenties treating blue jeans as a fallback, the thing I wore when I couldn't be bothered to decide, and it took a holiday where I'd packed nothing but denim and one jumper to notice how much work they were quietly doing.
They're best for the stretch of the year with no clear dress code: a Saturday that might involve a market and then lunch, a half term trip to see family, the first properly warm week when you want bare ankles but aren't ready for a dress yet. A straight leg pair with a white shirt and loafers covers a daytime wedding's arrival drinks without you looking like you've tried too hard, and the same jeans with a jumper and boots do the school run and then a supermarket run without changing. Where they come unstuck is anywhere formal or genuinely smart, a work event with a strict dress code, a funeral, any evening where the invite says "dressy" and means it. Dark denim can edge towards smart casual if everything else is doing the lifting, but no amount of ironing turns jeans into trousers, and pretending otherwise is how you end up overdressed in your head and underdressed on the doorstep.
What they clash with is anything else trying to be the loud part of the outfit. Heavy statement knitwear in a busy pattern, a lot of jewellery, a bag with hardware everywhere, all of it fights the jeans for attention and nobody wins, you just look like you got dressed in a hurry in two different decades. Light wash with anything else pale and stonewashed goes slightly dated, like you're auditioning for a nineties catalogue, and a very distressed, heavily ripped pair sits oddly next to anything tailored, a blazer especially, because the rips read as deliberately undone and the blazer reads as the opposite, and together they just look confused.
The plain combinations earn their keep precisely because they're plain. A good straight leg with a plain top and trainers is the one I reach for on days I can't make decisions about anything else, work boots and a jumper, sandals and a linen shirt in summer, the jeans doing nothing flashy while everything else gets to be slightly more interesting.
The detail that makes a good pair worth the fuss is the length sitting exactly on the shoe, not stacked, not hovering. Get that right once and you stop thinking about your jeans at all, which is the whole point.