A pair of brown boots is the thing you reach for when black feels too sharp and your trainers won't cut it, the boot that goes under jeans, under a skirt with thick tights, out the door without you having to think about it. They're meant to be the easy choice, the one that doesn't argue with half your wardrobe the way black sometimes does with warm tones, or trainers do with anything remotely smart.
Where they fall short is anywhere properly formal, a tan or chestnut boot next to tailoring can look like you got dressed in a hurry, and I learned that one stood next to a navy coat in a waiting room mirror, wondering why I looked like I'd borrowed half an outfit from someone else. They're also no good as your only winter boot if you need something waterproof for a proper downpour, most leather ones will cope with drizzle and little else unless they've been treated. For colour, go mid brown over anything too orange or too pale, a shade closer to conker than caramel wears with navy, grey, green and most other browns without a fight, and it hides scuffs far better than a pale tan does. A good pair ages properly, the leather creasing at the ankle in a way that looks lived in rather than knackered, while the cheap version cracks across the toe within a winter and the colour goes patchy and grey at the edges no matter what you do to it. Feed decent leather boots with a cream or wax every few weeks through fit one, let them dry away from radiators when they're wet, and they'll outlast three pairs of the cheap sort bought to replace each other. Before you buy, check the sole is stitched or glued properly rather than just pressed, run a thumbnail along the seam if you can, check the zip if there is one because that's always the first thing to go, and try them with the socks you'll actually wear them with, not the thin shop ones, because a boot that's snug in there feels completely different after an hour of walking.
They're brilliant for the in between months and for most days that don't need a suit, but they'll never do the job of a proper winter boot in a real storm, and they'll never quite sit right next to formal black. That's not a flaw in the boot, just a limit worth knowing before you ask it to do a job it was never built for.