There's a specific point in winter when your feet just give up. Mine usually happens around the third week back at work after Christmas, standing at a bus stop in something that looked lovely in the shop and felt like standing on two bricks within an hour. That's the day the comfort boots come out, and they don't go back in the cupboard until spring.
They're the ones that go under everything else you already own, which is really the point of them. Straight jeans tucked in or just resting on top, a long cardigan that comes down past the hip, a plain jumper dress in the dark months when you can't be bothered with tights that ladder the second you look at them. I wear mine with the same three things on rotation and never feel like I'm repeating an outfit because nobody's looking at my feet, they're looking at whether I've fallen over on the ice, which I haven't, because that's the other job these boots do. In the shop, check the sole before anything else, bend it in your hand, if it doesn't flex at all you'll be walking like you've got two planks strapped on by the time you get home. Check the inside for any seam sitting right where your ankle bone is, because that seam will introduce itself to you personally on a long walk. And always check how they feel after you've stood in them for a good ten minutes wandering round the shop, not just the thirty seconds sat on the bench, because that's when the truth comes out about whether there's enough room for your foot to actually spread a bit as the day goes on.
If you're starting from nothing, go for a plain ankle boot in black or brown with a low block heel or a flat sole, nothing with buckles or studs to get in the way, something that'll sit under jeans without a fuss and doesn't shout about itself. The difference between a good pair and a bad one shows up at about month three. A disappointing pair has a sole that's already splitting at the crease, stitching that's started to fray where the leather meets the sole, and a lining that's gone bobbly and damp smelling no matter how often you air them. A well made pair has a proper cushioned footbed that doesn't go flat after six weeks, stitching you can't see trying to come undone, and leather or a decent leather alternative that creases nicely rather than cracking. That cracking is the real giveaway, once it starts, it doesn't stop, and no amount of polish fixes it.