Pick one up and run a thumb across the nap before you even think about trying it on. Good suede has a bit of push back to it, a kind of depth, like velvet with manners. The cheap stuff feels thin and papery, almost plasticky at the edges, and you can tell in about two seconds that the first proper downpour is going to turn it patchy and sad.
If you've got none in the rack, start with an ankle boot in a mid brown or a grey that isn't too blue toned, because that's the one that goes with the most things without you having to think hard on a Tuesday morning. A chunky low heel rather than anything stiletto thin, something you can actually walk on without rolling an ankle on cobbles or a wet bus step. Suede reads as soft and a bit forgiving next to leather, which is exactly why it works for the bits of the year leather boots feel too hard edged for. Early autumn, when the ground's still dry and the air's just turned. Late spring, the same. It's not a boot for a proper Aberdeen winter, I'll say that now, slush and grit will wreck it, but for a dry cold day, a lunch out, a wander round a gallery, it's got a softness that trainers don't and wellies definitely don't.
The difference between a boot that lasts and one that's dead by Christmas comes down to a few things you can check with your hands. Real suede has that slightly fibrous, almost dusty feel, and it should be even all over, not shiny in patches where it's been treated to hide a cheaper hide underneath. Press the sole, it should have a bit of flex at the ball of the foot and not just crease like cardboard at the first wear. Check the stitching round the welt, if you can see glue instead of thread, that's your answer. Zips matter more than people give them credit for, a flimsy one will stick after a month of being pulled over a calf, so run it up and down twice in the shop, don't just trust the look of it. And always ask yourself if it could be resoled, because a boot that can only be resoled by throwing it in the bin isn't really a boot, it's a few months of wear with a receipt.
Treat it with a protector before the first proper outing, keep a suede brush somewhere you'll actually use it, and you'll get far more out of one than the price tag suggests. The right pair earns its spot by the door quietly, no drama, just there when the weather behaves.