The question I get most about brunch outfits is whether they need to be a dress, and they don't. The whole point of the category is that it sits between proper going out and pyjamas on the sofa, so what you actually want is something that looks like you made an effort without looking like you tried for an hour. A good knit with proper trousers does the job just as well as a dress, often better, because you're going to be sat down eating pastries for the best part of two hours.
What it shouldn't be worn with is anything that needs constant adjusting. Stiff new denim that digs in when you sit, a wrap top that gapes the second you reach for the coffee pot, a dress so fitted you're conscious of every croissant going in. I made that mistake with a bodycon midi that felt fine standing up in the shop and then spent an entire brunch feeling like a sausage reconsidering its casing. Anything with a lot of structure round the middle is working against you here, because the whole point of the meal is comfortable eating, not holding your stomach in for the camera.
On fit, the trick is to size for sitting down, not standing up. Trousers should have a bit of give in the waistband, knits should be soft enough that they drape rather than cling, and anything with buttons across the chest needs checking seated, because that's where gaping shows up, never on the hanger. Fabric feel matters more than people think for this one. A jersey or a fine knit that moves with you will survive a long table and a few refills far better than something crisp and unforgiving that creases the second you lean on your elbows, which, let's be honest, you will.
Brunch outfits suit the loose, unhurried end of the week, so they're really a weekend thing rather than a weekday one, and they shift with the year more than you'd expect. In the warmer months a lighter dress or a linen mix top earns its keep because you're often outside, maybe at a table in the sun, and anything heavy gets uncomfortable fast. In fur the colder months, I lean on textured knits and a good coat that comes off easily indoors, because nothing kills the mood faster than wrestling out of five layers in a narrow cafe doorway while everyone waits to sit down.
If I had to pick one quality to prioritise above everything else, it's softness against the skin and some stretch at the waist. Everything else, the colour, the print, the cut, is personal taste, and brunch is forgiving enough to let you have it.