Occasion wear used to mean one shape, really, the fitted mini or the slightly stiff midi that looked like it was built for a photograph rather than an actual evening. That has loosened up a lot in the last few years, more drape, more adjustable straps, more things you can actually sit down in through a meal, and honestly it is better for it, because not every invite deserves a dress that only works standing up.
Fit is where most of these pieces win or lose you. Anything with a fitted bodice needs to be tried sitting as well as standing, because that is when a dress tells you the truth about whether it is going to dig in by nine o'clock. Look closely at where the waist actually sits, a lot of high street occasion pieces put it an inch higher than your natural waist, which is fine until you have eaten anything. Jumpsuits are worth checking in the crotch and rise before you worry about anything else, since that is the bit that goes wrong first. If you are starting from nothing, go for one piece that covers the most ground, a dress in a shape that is neither too fitted nor too shapeless, something you could wear to a wedding with heels and to a work dinner with flats and a jacket, because that one piece will get more wear than three niche ones sitting unworn at the back.
On colour, the easiest place to start is somewhere between navy, bottle green and a deep berry, all of which read as dressed up without looking like you are trying to match a theme. Black is obviously safe but it photographs flatter than the richer tones and can look like you grabbed it in a rush. Prints are lovely but harder to repeat without people clocking it, so if you want something you can wear to more than one event without comment, a solid colour in a good fabric will take you further. On construction, the difference between a dress that lasts and one that dies after two wears is almost always in the lining, the seams under the arms, and whether the zip is sewn in properly rather than just glued and hoped for. Cheap fabric clings in the wrong places and creases the second you sit down, while a slightly heavier fabric with some structure holds its shape through a long night and a bad wash too.
If you are choosing one thing to start with, make it the deep bottle green. It does more jobs than black without trying half as hard.