The question I get asked most about cropped jackets is whether they actually work on a shorter frame, or whether they just make everything look cut in half. Honest answer, it depends entirely on where the crop sits. Just above the hip bone, not at the natural waist, and it elongates the leg rather than chopping you off at the middle.
Cropped jackets earn their place in spring and autumn more than anywhere else. Over a dress for something that counts as an occasion without feeling dressed up. Thrown over a plain top and jeans on a day that starts cold and warms up by lunchtime, when a full length coat would just end up tied round your waist by three o'clock. They're not built for proper winter, a cropped jacket and a howling gale are not friends, but for that in between weather where you need something on but not much, they're hard to beat. Denim versions do the casual end of this well, boxy tweed or boucle ones do the smarter end, and a good leather or faux leather crop sits nicely in between.
The difference between one that lasts and one that's had it by November is mostly in the shoulder and the lining. A cheap crop often has nothing holding the shoulder shape, so it collapses the first time you wear it with a bag on that side, and you end up with a lumpy little epaulette of fabric that won't sit back down. Look for proper interfacing, a bit of structure in the shoulder seam, and a lining, even a thin one, because an unlined jacket in cheap fabric will cling and crease in a way that reads tired by midday. Boucle and tweed ones are only as good as the weave, a loose cheap weave bobbles and thins at the elbow within a season, a tighter one holds. Denim wants a bit of weight to it, anything too light goes limp and loses its shape at the cuff. Zips should run smoothly without catching the lining, and buttons should feel properly sewn on, not glued or barely tacked.
Worn regularly, a good one softens rather than wears out. Denim fades in a way that looks better with age, tweed and boucle relax slightly at the elbow and cuff but keep their shape if the weave was decent to start with, leather develops a bit of character at the fold lines that honestly improves it. Wash denim ones rarely and inside out, keep tweed and boucle away from the washing machine entirely and have them dry cleaned if they need it, and let leather breathe on a proper hanger rather than folded in a drawer. After a year of real wear, the good ones look lived in rather than tired, which is really the whole point of buying one at all.