The mistake is buying a blazer dress a size up because it looks like it needs room, then wondering why it hangs like a sack by lunchtime. A blazer dress only works if it fits through the shoulder and nips in somewhere, waist or belt, otherwise you're just wearing an oversized jacket with no trousers, and that reads as unfinished rather than deliberate. Try it sitting down before you buy it. That's the real test, not standing in front of a mirror with your shoulders back.
The good ones earn their structure over months rather than losing it. A proper one, with a bit of weight to the fabric and real shoulder padding, keeps its shape wash after wash, and the lapels stay crisp instead of going soft and droopy like a cardigan pretending to be smart. Cheap versions crease across the stomach the second you sit down for an hour, and no amount of hanging it up overnight fixes that, you can see the fold lines through the whole next day. Hang it, don't fold it, and if it's got any wool in the mix a steam rather than an iron will save the lapels. On the pairing front, this is one of the few dresses that doesn't need much help, a pair of plain court shoes or boots and it's done, though I've taken to wearing mine over a thin polo neck in the colder months, which fixes the slightly bare feeling at the collarbone without adding bulk under the shoulders. Belts are worth having a few of, because a thin one changes the whole proportion if the dress runs a bit boxy on you. Colour wise, I'd steer away from very pale shades unless you enjoy dry cleaning, they show every bit of chair arm and train seat. Navy, charcoal, and a deep bottle green have all been kinder to me than black, which can look slightly severe and flat under office lighting, whereas the others still look considered without trying so hard. Occasion wise, this is a genuine crossover piece, sharp enough for anything that needs you looking organised, relaxed enough for a lunch or a wedding if you swap the shoes, and it earns its keep most in spring and autumn when a coat over the top is still sensible but you don't want full winter layers underneath.
If you're buying your first one, go for the charcoal. It hides more than navy, flatters more than black, and you'll reach for it on days you haven't planned an outfit at all.