The first thing I do with a halter dress is put my arms up over my head, right there in the changing room, before I even look in the mirror properly. If the neckline gapes or the back panel rides up to show the whole clasp, that's the dress telling me what it'll do on a dance floor or halfway through a long dinner. A good halter stays put when you reach for something on a high shelf. A bad one turns into a performance where you're constantly tugging the neck back into place.
It's not a shape for every chest or every bra situation, and I think it's worth saying plainly. If you're larger busted, a lot of halters put all the support on two thin straps around your neck, which gets uncomfortable fast and can leave marks by the end of the night. Backless and strapless bras help, but they're not a fix for a dress that's badly drafted underneath. It's also a bad choice for anyone who hates their shoulders on show, since the whole point of the shape is open shoulders and a bare upper back, there's no hiding that with a cardigan without losing the dress entirely. For fit, go by your ribcage and bust measurement rather than your usual dress size, because halters are cut to sit close under the arm and a size that's right everywhere else can still cut in at the sides. Watch for gapping at the front, which usually means the neckline's cut too wide for your frame, and check the tie or clasp sits flat against your neck rather than digging in, that's the difference between wearing it for an evening and fighting it for an evening.
Where the good ones separate themselves is in the fabric and the bit you can't see from the front. A halter in a heavier viscose or a proper crepe will skim rather than cling, and it moves with you instead of twisting round your middle, which thin polyester almost always does by about nine o'clock. Check the neck strap itself, a wider band or one with a bit of structure sewn in will hold its shape far longer than a flimsy spaghetti tie that stretches out after two wears and never sits the same again. Look at the back too, a dress with a proper fitted panel or a low tie that adjusts is going to behave better than one that's just two strings and hope. Cheap hardware, a clasp that's already stiff on the hanger, is usually a sign the rest of the construction hasn't had much thought either.
This suits anyone who wants their shoulders and collarbones to do the talking and doesn't mind a dress that needs checking in the mirror before it needs checking on the dance floor.