Off shoulder dresses have a reputation for being the thing you wear once, to one wedding, and then shove to the back of the rail because the neckline kept slipping or the sleeves dug in wherever they sat. I think that reputation is only half fair. A cheap one does slip, constantly, because the elastic is doing all the work and elastic on its own can't hold a line across the collarbone for a whole afternoon. A well cut one has a bit of structure built into the band, sometimes boning, sometimes just a denser weave, and that structure is the entire difference between fidgeting with it every ten minutes and forgetting you've got it on.
Where it falls apart is in the layering. Off shoulder dresses clash with anything that wants to sit on the shoulder itself, so a cropped jacket or a cardigan pulled up high just cancels out the whole point of the neckline, you end up paying for an architectural feature and then hiding it. A thin shawl or a blazer worn properly off the shoulders alongside it works better than most jackets. On colour, I'd steer towards solid shades over busy prints, because the neckline is already doing a lot visually and a loud pattern competing with bare shoulders tends to look fussy rather than finished. Deep colours, a bottle green, a rust, a good black, photograph less well than they wear, if that makes sense, they're more forgiving in person than online. For occasions, this is a warm weather dress through and through, a garden do, a dinner outside, a holiday where you're not walking far and not fighting a wind, because any kind of breeze turns a loose neckline into a full time job keeping it up. It is the wrong choice for anything involving a coat, a commute, or a hill, since the whole appeal disappears under outerwear and reappears as a cold collarbone.
Fabric with a bit of weight, a structured band, and sleeves that sit properly on the upper arm rather than sliding, that's the version worth paying for.
Hand wash it or use a gentle cycle in a bag, the elastic in that neckline won't survive many hot washes.