My first prom dress came from a shop that's long gone now, a stiff lilac satin thing with a built in bra cup that never once matched my actual size. It taught me that cheap satin creases if you so much as sit down, and that you should always, always sit down in a dress before you buy it, not just stand in front of the mirror looking hopeful.
Satin is still the thing I'd warn people about most, because it photographs beautifully and behaves terribly. It clings to anything underneath it, shows every seam of the wrong underwear, and picks up creases the second you fold your arms or sit in a car for twenty minutes. Pair it with anything shiny on top, a metallic clutch, a sequinned wrap, and the whole look stops reading as glamorous and starts reading as a school play about a disco. Keep the accessories matte if the dress itself has any shine at all, and let one element do the talking.
Prom sits in a strange little window, usually early summer, usually one specific evening that matters more than it will feel like it matters in five years. That means you want something that can survive a few hours of standing, a car journey, a hall that's either freezing or boiling depending on the ventilation, and a hundred photographs taken by other people's parents. Heavier fabrics with a bit of structure hold up better across that stretch than anything floaty and light, because floaty is gorgeous for the first twenty minutes and a nightmare by the time everyone's dancing.
Before you buy, check the lining properly, not just the outer layer. A lot of prom dresses look rich from the outside and feel like a bin bag against your skin, which you will notice within the hour. Check where the zip sits and whether it's hidden or likely to gape under strain, because this is a dress you'll be wearing for longer than you'd wear almost anything else you own that year. And check the hem length sitting down as well as standing, since a dress that grazes the floor standing up can trip you the second you take a step, which nobody tells you until you're the one grabbing a banister.
This suits anyone who wants one evening to feel deliberate, not perfect, just properly thought through, whatever age that evening happens to land on.