A good red dress looks like it was mixed specifically for your skin, warm or cool or somewhere in between, and a poor one looks like it was mixed for nobody, just "red" off a chart, and you can spot the difference from across a room before you've even clocked the fit. The good one makes people ask where it's from. The poor one makes you look slightly unwell, which is a lot to ask of one colour.
Keep the rest of the outfit quiet around it. This is not the dress for a busy print coat, a patterned bag, or shoes that want their own moment, because red is already doing all the talking and anything else shouting back just turns into noise. Plain black, nude, white or tan accessories let it do its job. Gold hardware tends to sit better with red than silver, though I'd never say that's a rule you'd get arrested for breaking.
It is not the easiest colour for every context, and I think people pretend otherwise. Office dress codes can be funny about it, it photographs harder under orange indoor lighting than you'd expect, and if you run on the paler side with pink undertones, some reds will fight your face rather than flatter it. Try it in daylight before you commit, not under shop lighting designed to make everything look rich and expensive.
What separates a dress that earns its colour from one that just has it dyed on comes down to the fabric and the finish. A flat, slightly stiff weave holds red better than a thin jersey, which can look washed out and a bit sad under normal light. Check the lining too, a cheap one shows through at the seams and kills the depth of the colour from the inside out. Stitching should sit flush, not puckered, and any zip should be hidden properly, not peeking through like an afterthought.
On shade, true red and a red with a touch of blue in it, nearer wine without being wine, are the easiest to live with over time. They don't date the way a very orange red can, and they go with denim, with a plain trench, with black tights and boots in a way that needs no thought at all. Brighter reds are brilliant but they ask more of you, they want confidence and the right occasion rather than a quiet Tuesday.
Worn right, it is the one colour in the dress rail that never needs explaining.