There's a particular kind of warm evening, usually right at the end of August when the heat has gone a bit syrupy and nobody wants anything touching their skin, when a slip dress stops being a dress and starts being the only sensible option in the flat. I've reached for mine on nights too hot for anything with a waistband, and on cold December ones too, layered under a jumper, which tells you most of what you need to know about how hard this shape works once you stop treating it as a single season thing.
It has its enemies, though. A slip dress and a padded, structured bra is a losing combination, you'll see every seam and strap through the fabric by nine in the evening, so you either go without or find something seamless and soft. Thick opaque tights underneath change the whole line and usually for the worse, dragging the fabric and killing the drape that's the entire point of the thing. Chunky cable knit cardigans on top tend to fight it rather than finish it, the stiffness of the knit against the fluid satin just looks like two outfits that got stuck together. Simple wins here. A fine cotton tee, a soft blazer, a leather jacket, something that doesn't compete with the movement.
Where it actually earns its place is high summer, obviously, but also as the one piece that carries you through a slightly awkward run of occasions in cooler months, a party, a dinner, a wedding with a loose dress code, worn with boots and a coat rather than sandals. Where it falls apart is anywhere you need to move properly or stand in wind. I wore a cheap one on a blustery pier in April and spent the whole time holding the hem down with one hand and my drink with the other, which is not the relaxed image the dress is supposedly selling. It's also not an office dress, however you dress it down, and it's not forgiving if you're self conscious about anything clingy, because bias cut satin finds every lump going.
The difference between a good one and a bad one is almost always in the weight of the fabric and the cut of the seams. Thin, slippery polyester catches on tights, rides up when you sit, and goes see through under any light stronger than a lamp. A proper weight, whether that's a heavier viscose or a good satin blend, has enough body to hang straight and skim rather than cling. Proper French seams rather than overlocked ones stop it fraying after two washes, and adjustable straps are worth checking before you buy, because a fixed strap that's half an inch too long will ruin the whole neckline all night.
Buy it in the right weight and it's one of the few dresses that genuinely moves with the year rather than against it.