A smock dress is the one you grab when you can't face anything with a waistband, and I mean that as a compliment. It hangs from the shoulders or just under the bust and does its own thing from there, so there's no seam digging in after lunch, no fabric creasing into a crease that stays put for the afternoon. If you've never owned one, start with a plain cotton version in a colour you already wear, not a busy print, because the shape is already doing plenty and a loud print on top of it can tip into maternity wear territory, which some of us have accidentally walked into a changing room wearing before realising why the assistant looked at us a certain way.
The fit question is really a length and fabric question, not a size one. Too short and it reads a bit smock as in overall, too long and heavy fabric and it can swamp you, so look for something that hits mid thigh to just above the knee unless you're deliberately going longer with boots. Thin, drapey cotton or linen blends move with you, while anything stiff or with too much volume in the body will add width you didn't ask for, especially around the arms and shoulders where the gathering usually sits. If you're short, a dress with the gather higher up, nearer the collarbone, tends to look less like a tent. Sleeves are worth checking too, a smock with a proper set in sleeve sits better than one that's just an armhole cut into the gathered body, which can gape when you reach for something on a shelf.
Underneath, a smock dress wants simple things. Trainers or flat boots and bare legs in warmer months, tights and ankle boots when it turns cold, a denim jacket thrown over when the weather can't decide, which in most of the country is most of the year. A good one has decent weight to the cotton, so it doesn't cling or go see through in bright sun, proper finished seams rather than raw edges that fray after two washes, and buttons or ties that are sewn on properly rather than glued, because a loose button down the front on day one tells you everything about how the rest of it was made. Linen ones crease, that's just linen, but a well cut smock crumples in a way that looks deliberate rather than slept in.
Reach for it on days you want to look dressed without getting dressed, hot commutes, long lunches, the kind of day where tight clothes would be the last straw.