The first white dress I owned cost about eighteen pounds, from a shop that's long since closed, and it taught me the hard way that white cotton without a lining goes see through in direct sun exactly when you're stood in a car park waiting for a bus. Lesson learned: check what's underneath before you check the size.
Stark white, the kind that looks like it's been through a hospital wash, is the hardest version to live with day to day. It shows everything, every bit of makeup, every splash from a bus going through a puddle, and it needs constant attention to stay looking fresh past about eleven in the morning. Off white, ivory, bone, anything with a bit of cream or oatmeal running through it, is far more forgiving against most skin tones and doesn't demand the same vigilance. Finish matters just as much as shade: a slubby linen or a brushed cotton hides creasing and the odd mark far better than anything shiny or satin, which shows every crease by lunchtime and every mark forever. A plain white dress is also one of the easiest things to build a day around, precisely because it asks so little of the rest of what you own. A denim jacket over it in spring, a leather jacket and boots when the weather turns sharper, gold jewellery rather than silver if you want it to look like a choice rather than an accident, a cardigan in whatever colour you already wear most for the bits of the year that can't settle. If you've got none and you're starting from scratch, go for a midi in a cotton with some structure to it, properly lined, in an off white rather than a true one, because that's the version that gets worn on an ordinary Tuesday rather than saved for one occasion a year and then forgotten in the wardrobe.
White dresses and British weather have an uneasy relationship, and no amount of good intentions changes that. Summer is the obvious home for one, bare legs and sandals when the sun actually shows up, but it copes with the shoulder seasons too if you treat it as a base layer rather than the whole outfit, tights and ankle boots and a coat thrown over the top on a coolish spring day. Where it genuinely struggles is anything involving mud, grass, a damp train seat, or a toddler with a biscuit, and I say that having ruined one at a lovely afternoon thing by sitting on a bench that had just been painted. Rain itself isn't really the enemy so much as everything rain brings with it, the splashback off a road, the patch on a seat nobody warns you about. None of that means skip white, it just means it isn't the dress for a day with a commute and a downpour both already pencilled in.
One small thing nobody puts on the label: a decent white dress needs a proper slip or lining from the start, not one bought in a panic the first time you wear it in daylight.
So the question I always ask myself in the shop is this: would I still want to wear this after dark, in normal shoes, on an ordinary day, or am I only picturing the one perfect afternoon that might never actually turn up?