I used to think wrap dresses were a cheat, something that looked like effort without the fitting room battle, and then I actually tried one on properly rather than just holding it up in the mirror, and the tie did something no zip has ever managed on me. It sat at my actual waist, not wherever the pattern cutter guessed it might be. That's the whole pitch, really: it adjusts to you rather than asking you to adjust to it.
These earn their place at the sort of things where you're not sure how formal to go, a christening, a lunch that might turn into drinks, a work do where half the room is in jeans and the other half in heels. They're good from late spring right through to early autumn in a lighter fabric, and if you find one in a heavier jersey or a brushed knit, it'll take you through fitted parts of the year, with tights and boots, without looking like you've just wandered in from the beach. What they're not brilliant for is anything very windy or very formal. A proper wedding, I'd think twice.
How it wears over time comes down almost entirely to the tie and the skirt. A good one has a tie long enough to wrap round twice and still knot properly, because the single pass versions work loose by lunchtime, and I've stood in a corridor retying mine more than once. The skirt should have enough weight to swing rather than cling, which usually means a bit of viscose or a wool blend in the mix rather than a thin, slippery polyester that rides up when you sit down. Wash it on a cool cycle, fold rather than hang if the fabric has any give, and check the inside tie loop, the bit that actually holds the whole dress closed, because on cheaper ones it's a flimsy bit of ribbon that pulls away from the seam within a few wears.
A well made wrap dress has proper weight in the hand, a tie that's sewn into the seam rather than stuck on as an afterthought, and a wrap that overlaps generously enough that it doesn't gape when you move your arms. Pair it with flat boots and a jacket you'd wear anywhere, or sandals and nothing else in warmer weather, it doesn't ask for much. The honest limit is that it relies entirely on that tie staying put, and on a breezy day, or after one too many good lunches, you'll find yourself checking it.