There's a particular five minutes most mornings go through: you've got the outfit sorted, you've tried the flat shoes, and the whole thing looks like you gave up halfway through getting dressed. That's when heels earn their place on the floor by the door rather than the back of the wardrobe. A pair of block heels under a plain dress, a court shoe with wide leg trousers, even a kitten heel with jeans when you want to look like you tried without looking like you tried too hard. They do a specific job flats can't, which is make an ordinary outfit look finished in about four seconds.
Getting the fit right matters more with heels than almost anything else you'll buy, because a bad fit doesn't just pinch, it changes how you walk, and that shows. Go half a size up if the style is a pointed court, since leather gives at the sides but never at the length, and a toe that's jammed in will have you hobbling by lunchtime no matter how good it looked in the shop mirror. Ankle straps should sit snug, not loose, or you'll spend the whole day hitching them. Block heels forgive a slightly wrong size far better than a stiletto does, which punishes every error immediately.
What they clash with is less about colour and more about proportion. A delicate strappy heel under a very long, heavy trouser hem just disappears, and you've bought a nice shoe for nobody to see. Thick ankle socks under anything with a strap look like an accident rather than a choice. And a very structured, buckled heel fights for attention with a busy print dress, one of them has to be the quiet one.
Over months, the wear tells you what you bought. Patent will crack at the crease before it does anything else, suede needs a protector spray before its first proper outing, not after the first rainy walk ruins it, and heel tips wear down flat on anyone who walks on pavement daily, long before the rest of the shoe looks tired. A decent cobbler fixes that for the price of a coffee, and it's worth doing before the metal underneath starts clicking on tile floors, which is an undignified sound.
Where heels are simply the wrong choice is any day with real walking in it, cobbles, long platform waits, anything over about an hour on your feet without a sit down. No shoe is worth a blister you can feel through next week's shoes too.
Tomorrow I'd put a mid block heel with straight leg trousers and a plain jumper, and call it done before I've had my tea.