It clicked for me on a Tuesday when I'd worn the same pair of indigo jeans with a plain white shirt, flat boots and nothing else trying, and caught myself in a shop window looking like I'd made an effort I hadn't actually made. That's the thing with a proper dark indigo wash, it does a sort of quiet styling job on its own, no fading, no whiskering, no distressed bits asking for attention. Dress it up, dress it down, it just sits there looking sorted.
Where it falls short is anywhere you want jeans to disappear completely, a big night out where you want black, or stupidly hot weather when a dark wash feels like wearing a radiator. It's also not the one to reach for if you're after that worn in, lived in look straight off the peg, because indigo by nature looks newer for longer, which is either exactly what you want or completely the opposite, depending on your mood. As for wear, a decent pair softens at the knee and hip crease over a few months without losing shape everywhere else, and the colour holds if you're sensible about washing, inside out, cold, as infrequent as you can stand, because heat and friction are what pull indigo dye out fastest, not time itself. I made the mistake early on of chucking a new pair in with a load of whites because I couldn't be bothered sorting colours, and spent the next year with jeans that looked like they'd been left in a bath of weak tea and a top that had gone faintly blue at the collar. Hang them to dry if you can, tumble drying is basically an ageing machine for denim.
The difference between a pair that earns its spot and one that sulks in a drawer is almost always in the weight and the stitching. A proper one has some heft to it, enough that it doesn't flap about or bag out at the knee by lunchtime, and the inside seams feel flat and even rather than raw and fraying from the first wear. Cheaper versions often use a thinner dye that sits on the surface rather than through the fibre, so a few washes in you can see it lifting unevenly, patchy rather than gently worn. Good rivets and a solid button that doesn't wobble in its setting are small things, but they're usually the first to go on a disappointing pair, and once a button starts spinning loose, it's only a matter of time.
The one mistake worth avoiding is buying indigo jeans a size down expecting the stretch to sort it out by the end of the day. It rarely does, and you'll spend eight hours tugging at the waistband instead of wearing them properly.