I spent years treating wedge sandals as the sensible middle class compromise, the shoe for a woman who's given up but hasn't told anyone yet. Then I wore a decent pair to a wedding that involved a lot of grass and an outdoor bar with no seating, and I understood why they exist. Nothing else that day would have got me from the ceremony to the taxi without a limp.
What they don't sit well with is anything delicate. A floaty midi dress on a wedge can tip you into looking like you're wearing the shoe wrong, there's a heaviness to the sole that wants a bit of structure above it, a stiffer linen trouser, a denim skirt, something with its own weight. Pair them with something too soft and billowy and you get this odd mismatch, like the outfit's arguing with its own feet. They also don't love a very tailored, sharp office look, the kind of thing that wants a clean heel or a flat loafer. Wedges sit in their own category, more holiday than boardroom, and trying to make them formal usually just makes them look like you ran out of other shoes.
The honest limit is grip and speed. A cheap wedge, the kind with a foam sole and a bit of fabric glued over it, will rub at the inner edge of your foot within an hour and the glue starts giving way within a season, I've had the wedge separate from the sole on a pavement in actual public. A better made one, proper cork or a wrapped leather wedge, flexes slightly differently and doesn't dig in the same way, but even then, if you need to move fast, catch a bus, chase a child, wedges are not built for it. The sole doesn't bend the way a flat does, so there's a slight clomp to any kind of hurry. Fit wise, try them on later in the day when your feet have swollen a bit, and go up half a size if you're between, because wedges show every millimetre of tightness across the toes in a way flats forgive. Check the back strap too, a loose one will have your heel lifting slightly with every step, which is exhausting over a few hours.
They age in a way that's quite visible. The leather ones soften and the cork darkens nicely at the edges, start looking like they belong to you. The cheap ones just go grey and start crumbling at the heel, and there's no softening that, only replacing it.