Most people buy clogs a size up, convinced the wooden base needs room to flex, and end up walking out of them by lunchtime because clogs do not stretch or soften the way a trainer does. The sole stays exactly the shape it was made in, so if your foot slides forward every time you go downstairs, that is not something a few wears will fix.
They are brilliant for the bits of the week that involve standing more than walking fast, which rules out a frantic commute but makes them excellent for a long day on your feet, a weekend of errands, or any time you want something you can step into without bending down. They are not made for rain, and a wet pavement with a leather sole underneath you is a genuine hazard, so think spring through early autumn, dry days, pavements rather than cobbles. On a practical level, they pair with almost anything that sits above the ankle, so a straight leg trouser, a midi skirt, or bare legs in warmer months all work, because the clog does the visual heavy lifting and the rest of the outfit just needs to stay out of its way. A fitted sock looks deliberate with them, a slouchy one looks like you got dressed in a hurry, which some days is also fine.
On colour, a mid brown or a natural tan finish is the easiest thing to own, because it goes with navy, black, denim and most prints without you having to think about it, and scuffs show up less on a finish that already has some variation in it. Black is smarter but shows every scrape along the toe within a month. Pale or painted finishes look wonderful in a shop and need babying that most of us do not have time for. The leather on a decent pair will crease and darken slightly where your foot flexes, and that is not damage, that is the shoe starting to fit you specifically rather than anyone. Wipe them down rather than scrub them, keep them away from direct heat when they are wet, and feed the leather with a cream or wax every so often or it will dry out and crack along that flex line, which is the one fault you cannot fix after the fact.
If I were choosing one pair to start with, I would go for a plain mid brown with no detailing, because it hides the normal wear and goes with the widest run of things already hanging in your wardrobe.