A good black sock has a bit of weight to it before it's even on your foot, a density you can feel when you scrunch it in your hand. Cheap ones feel papery, almost hollow, and you know before you've even pulled them on that they'll be at your ankles by lunchtime.
The difference between a sock that lasts and one that's bin material by the third wash usually comes down to what's happened at the heel and toe. A proper reinforced heel, a toe seam that's flat rather than a little ridge you can feel pressing into your skin all day, and a cuff with real elastic recovery rather than the sad stretched out ribbing you get on the ones sold in packs of ten for not very much. Cotton with a bit of nylon or elastane mixed in behaves far better than pure cotton, which goes baggy at the ankle within a fortnight. Hold two pairs up to the light if you can, the cheaper weave often shows gaps you'd never notice until they're on your foot and gone thin at the ball within a month. And black fades unevenly if the dye's poor, so you end up with one sock a shade greyer than its partner, which is a very specific kind of annoying when you're getting dressed in the dark for an early shift.
Where black socks actually let you down is in anything sheer or cropped, a pair of ankle grazer trousers with a gap of leg showing works, but a long maxi skirt with trainers and show off socks underneath can look like an afterthought rather than a choice, unless that's genuinely the look you're going for. They also clash, oddly, with very delicate or dressy shoes, a strappy sandal and visible black sock reads as either very fashion forward or like you got dressed in a hurry, and there's not much middle ground. And obviously, if you're after any texture or personality in an outfit from the ankle down, a plain black sock isn't doing that job, it's the quiet one in the room by design, not by accident.
They're also not the answer for anyone who runs warm or stands for long stretches, thick cotton traps heat and a thin, badly ventilated sock can leave your feet damp by mid afternoon, which is its own kind of discomfort nobody warns you about. For that, something with a bit of breathable structure matters more than the colour ever will.
Given enough washes, the good ones soften rather than thin, the elastic staying put at the cuff while the fabric gets that slightly worn in, almost better feel against the skin, whereas the bad ones just go see through at the heel and start sliding down inside your shoe, which is how you end up fishing around under a desk trying to pull one back up without anyone noticing.
If none of these are quite right, sneaker socks might be.