The thing nobody tells you about a black bikini is that it doesn't stay black. Give it a season of chlorine, salt water and sun cream and you'll notice it first at the seams, a faint rusty brown creeping in where the fabric's been stretched hardest. By the second summer the whole thing can look more aubergine than black, especially if you've only ever rinsed it in cold tap water and hoped for the best.
It's not really a colour that clashes with other colours, it clashes with context. Pair it with very bright gold jewellery and cheap looking hardware on the straps and the whole thing reads costume rather than swimwear. Worn with obvious white tan lines and a fresh burn, it does you no favours either, it just frames the red. The flattering version of a black bikini is clean lines against bare, slightly tanned skin and not much else fighting for attention.
What actually separates a good one from a disappointing one is almost never visible on the hanger. Look at the lining first, a proper one is a separate layer of fabric, not just the same print doubled over, and it stops the whole thing going see through the moment it's wet. Feel the fabric itself: a decent nylon and elastane blend holds its shape and snaps back, cheaper polyester mixes go baggy at the bum within a fortnight. Check the seams are flatlocked rather than just overlocked, and give the ties a proper tug, metal rings and sliders should feel solid, not like they'll seize up with salt the first week.
For ease of wear, go for a true matte black over anything with a shine or a metallic thread running through it, shiny black shows every crease and every bit of sand that's stuck to sun cream. A slightly textured crinkle fabric hides more than a flat jersey does, and it dries faster too, which matters more than people admit when you're putting it back on damp the next morning. Black does wash most skin tones out a touch if you're very pale and not yet tanned, it can look harsh rather than smart in May before anyone's seen the sun, and it shows every grain of sand and every bit of white residue from sun cream in a way that a patterned bikini simply doesn't.
If you're still deciding, have a look at bandeau bikinis too.