The first thing I do with a cream top is hold it up against a window. Proper daylight shows up every shadow of grey or pink hiding in the fabric, and cream is the one colour where that matters more than almost anything else, because the wrong undertone next to your skin can make you look like you've not slept.
Cream earns its spot from early spring right through to the start of winter, which is longer than white manages in most people's heads. It works under a blazer for something that needs to look put together without trying too hard, it works on its own in warmer months when white feels too stark and too much like it needs bleach after one wear, and it works as a base layer under knitwear once the weather turns, where a strip of it at the collar or cuff looks deliberate rather than accidental. I've worn the same cream shirt to a lunch, to a school thing, and under a coat to a function, and it looked like three different outfits because of what went round it, not because the top changed at all.
In an ordinary wardrobe it sits next to almost everything without a fight. Denim, obviously, but it's particularly good against camel, tan and chocolate brown, tones that would look flat against white but warm up properly against cream. Black trousers underneath stop it looking too soft, gold jewellery suits it far more than silver does, and a khaki jacket over the top is one of my most reached for combinations because neither colour is trying to be the main event. Where a well made one shows itself is after a few washes. A good cotton or a proper viscose blend keeps its colour evenly, so it fades as a whole rather than yellowing under the arms first, which is the giveaway of a cheap one. Check the seams before you buy, not after: flat, neat stitching holds its shape wash after wash, while a loosely overlocked seam will start to pucker within a month and never sit right again. Buttons should feel like they're attached with intent, not glued on as an afterthought, because cream shows a missing button and a thread trail far more obviously than a patterned top ever would.
A cream top that's been through a summer in a bag, a few warm washes and a season of real wear should still look like itself, just softer.
If you're between sizes, go up rather than down, because cream pulls tight across the body in a way that draws the eye exactly where you don't want it.
Another good place to look is cream outfits.