I kept knitted tops out of the rotation for years because the one I owned pilled under the arms within a month and went bobbly across the stomach by week three, and I decided the whole category was a waste of money off the back of that single jumper. What changed my mind was realising I'd bought the cheapest one in the shop and blamed the entire style of top for a problem that was really just thin yarn and a bad weave.
They're still not right for everything, mind. Anything very fine knit clings to whatever's underneath it, so if you're not wearing the smoothest vest you own under it, every seam and every bra strap will announce itself by lunchtime. Heavier knits add bulk at the wrist and shoulder that fights with a fitted jacket, so I've learned to save those for days when I'm not layering anything structured on top. For fit, go a size down from what you'd normally take in a cotton top, because most knitted ones grow a little through the day and relax at the neckline, and check the ribbing at the hem and cuffs rather than the label, since a tight rib will hold its shape for months while a loose one stretches out within a few wears and never goes back. Sleeve length is the other thing I actually measure now, because a knitted sleeve that's even an inch too long bunches at the wrist and looks like you've borrowed it, while one that's slightly short just looks like a crop sleeve was the plan all along, which is far more forgiving. Fine merino and lambswool blends in a tighter knit tend to hold their line best, cashmere is gorgeous but shows every lean on a desk or car door within a week, so I treat mine like it's on loan.
Colour wise, the ones I actually reach for are the muted shades, oatmeal, a soft grey, a proper navy, because the slight texture of a knit already does enough visual work without a loud colour fighting it, and those three go under the same denim jacket and over the same straight leg jeans I've had for two years without ever looking repeated. A deep plum or bottle green earns its place for the colder months and still goes with the same jeans, while anything pastel shows marks from bag straps and coffee cups faster than you'd like. I wear mine tucked into trousers with trainers on an ordinary day and loose over a slip skirt when I want to look like I tried without actually trying.
Next time you're looking, run your thumb across the knit under the arm first, if it feels thin and loose there, it'll be bobbled before the season's out.