The real test of a ribbed top isn't day one, it's week six, when you've washed it a dozen times and it either still hugs where it should or has gone baggy at the waist and tight across the shoulders in a way that makes no sense. That's when you find out what you actually bought.
A good one starts with fabric that has proper recovery, so the rib springs back after a day of sitting rather than pooling out by mid afternoon. Thin and papery means it'll go see through at the chest within a month, and you'll be doing the thing where you hold it up to the light in the shop like that tells you anything useful, it doesn't, wash it first and then judge. The construction matters more than people admit for something this plain, flat seams at the shoulder and a decent hem rather than one that curls up after a tumble dry. Necklines are where cheap ones fall apart fastest, a scoop or crew that's cut too shallow will stretch into a boat neck by the third wear, so look for stitching that's close and even rather than one wobbly line of overlocking. The weight should feel like something, not nothing, a bit of body in your hand rather than a tee shirt pretending to be smart.
As for colour, I've gone off anything too stark. A pure white rib shows every mark and goes grey at the cuffs before the rest of it has even settled in, and a true black can look slightly cheap under certain lights, almost plasticky, which is annoying because black is the one you reach for most. The ones that actually get worn are the in between shades, a soft oatmeal, a dark green, a dusty brown, something that doesn't shout but still looks considered next to denim or a plain skirt. These sit well under a blazer without peeking out the wrong way, and they don't fight with a print the way a bright colour can when you're layering. For pairing, this is the top that quietly fixes a lot of outfits that feel half finished, tucked into trousers with a flat shoe for the day, or under a jacket with the sleeves pushed up for something that looks a bit more put together without trying very hard.
If you're starting with none, go for a mid weight crew neck in a neutral rather than black or white, long enough to tuck properly. It's the one that'll get worn on repeat and still look decent in month four.
It's the thing that makes an old pair of trousers look like you dressed on purpose.