The moment it clicked for me was a wrap top I put on for a client meeting that overran by forty minutes, then straight into a lunch I hadn't planned for, then a walk back in a bit of wind. Nine o'clock sharp, half past one still sitting right at the waist, no gaping at the front, no tugging at the tie. That's the whole case for a wrap top in one morning. Most tops have one job. This one somehow does smart, casual and windy car park without changing its mind halfway through.
It does have a weak point, and it's whatever you pair it with on the bottom half. Anything else with volume at the waist, a full skirt, wide palazzo trousers, a belted coat over the top, and you end up with fabric fighting fabric, bulk where you don't want it. Keep the bottom simple. Straight leg trousers, a pencil skirt, slim jeans, anything that gives the wrap room to do the one dramatic thing it does without competing with it. I made that mistake once with a gathered midi skirt and ended up looking like I was wearing two tops and no shape at all.
On the ageing front, it depends entirely on the fabric, and this is where I've been burned before. A cheap jersey wrap top will hold its shape for a few wears and then the tie starts to stretch and won't sit snug anymore, so you're retying it tighter each week until eventually it just gapes no matter what you do. A heavier jersey or a proper viscose blend behaves far better, keeps its recovery, and a cool hand wash or a gentle cycle in a bag will get you months out of it rather than weeks. Hang it rather than fold it, the wrap panel creases oddly if it's been squashed in a drawer, and that's not the kind of crease that drops out by lunchtime.
Where it earns its place is anywhere you need to look pulled together without trying too hard. Office days obviously, but also the kind of weekend lunch where you still want to look like you made an effort, or an evening where a plain top under a blazer would look flat but you don't want to commit to a dress. It works best from early spring through to early autumn on its own, and then quietly slides under a blazer or cardigan for the colder months without losing its shape. Go up a size if you're between two, because a wrap top that's slightly too snug across the bust will gape no matter how well you tie it.