I steered clear of zip tops for years, convinced they only worked on women with less chest than me, because every one I tried gaped open at the zip the second I lifted my arms to reach a top shelf. What changed my mind was trying one with a proper funnel neck and a zip set higher than I expected, which pulled everything in rather than letting it fall open.
A zip top is most useful from the start of autumn right through to the first properly warm week of spring, when a jumper feels like too much but a plain tee looks unfinished under a coat. Half zipped, it does casual Saturday without much thought; done right up to the collar, it covers the neck and throat on a day when the wind has an edge to it. I reach for mine under a denim jacket more than anything else, and it sits well under blazers too, as long as the collar doesn't clash with a shirt collar underneath, which some of the boxier ones do. With jeans it reads ordinary, with wide leg trousers and boots it reads like you made an effort, and both come from the same top, which is more than I can say for most things at the back of my drawer. Where it sits on the body matters more than the price tag did when I bought it: anything that stops right at the widest part of the hip will pull tight across the zip the second you sit down, so look for one that falls a few centimetres past that point if you don't want to spend the evening tugging the hem straight. The zip itself is what tells you how the top will age. Cheap teeth catch on scarves and necklaces within a few wears, and a zip that's already stiff out of the packet rarely loosens with wear, it just gets stiffer and starts sticking halfway up. Mine gets washed inside out and zipped right up before it goes in the machine, because a dangling zip pull is what scuffs the inside of a sleeve in the drum, and after four months of fairly regular wear it still looks like the day I bought it, which is not something I can say about the one I owned the year before.
The detail that makes a good one a pleasure rather than a chore is a zip pull with a bit of weight to it and a loop wide enough to get a finger through on a cold morning, rather than a thin metal tag you end up pinching between two nails. That small bit of hardware is the difference between a top you grab without thinking and one that sits in the drawer looking better than it actually is to put on.