I avoided chunky trainers for years because I thought they only worked on legs about a foot longer than mine, and on me they'd just look like I was wearing two small wheel arches. What changed was trying a pair on properly, in a mirror, in daylight, rather than deciding from a photo that they'd be a disaster. They weren't. The weight of the sole does something flattering to proportion that a flat trainer doesn't, and I'd spent a long time being wrong about that.
The difference between a good pair and a bad one is almost entirely in the sole unit and the stitching, not the colourway. A well made chunky trainer has layers of foam or rubber that are bonded cleanly, with no visible glue line and no seams that pucker where the upper meets the sole. Cheap ones look fine in the box and then the sole starts yellowing or peeling at the edge within a couple of months, which is heartbreaking when you've built a whole look around them. The upper matters too, proper leather or a dense mesh holds its shape and creases nicely with wear, while a flimsy synthetic one creases badly, in the wrong places, and looks tired rather than lived in. Hardware, eyelets, the little pull tab at the heel, should feel solid rather than stamped out of tin. On your body, keep the rest of the outfit lean. A chunky sole paired with wide leg trousers or a voluminous coat just doubles the bulk and swallows you. Straight or slightly tapered trousers, a fitted or cropped top, something with a clean line above the shoe, lets the trainer be the statement rather than one bulky thing fighting another.
Where they genuinely let you down is distance and rain. They're heavier than a normal trainer, so a long walking day leaves your legs more tired than you'd expect, and a lot of the chunkier soles have shallow tread patterns that go slick on wet pavement rather than gripping it. Spring and autumn are their best seasons, worn with ankle socks showing and a slightly cropped trouser. High summer in them feels overdressed and hot, and proper winter slush ruins the pale ones within a week, no matter how carefully you avoid puddles.
A month in, mine had creased hard across the toe and picked up a grey scuff along one side that I didn't even try to clean off, and they looked better than new. That slightly battered look, rather than box fresh, is the whole point of owning them.