Top Picks

ESME’S PICK
TINACUSTOMTinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Mary Janes for Women with Double Straps - Black / US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm
$99.40 TINACUSTOM

ELLIE’S PICK
TINACUSTOMTinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather T-Strap Buckle Square Toe High Block Heel Mary Janes Pumps Shoes - US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm / brown
$94.70 TINACUSTOM
How we pick
Nobody here is paid to push a brand. Chloe, Esme, Ellie, Imogen and Megan went through everything in mary janes the way you would on a lunch break, scrolling, squinting at the fabric, checking the price twice. What made the list is what they'd actually put in their own basket. We look for pieces that wash well, sit right and don't cost silly money for what they are, and we mix up the shops so you're not just looking at one high street name over and over. Prices and stock come straight from the retailers and change often, so it's always worth a quick check before you buy.
We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money
Under $5010 pieces

SCARLETDARKNESS
Enamel Drip-Glaze Hand-Painted Flower Earrings
$12.99 SCARLETDARKNESS
SCARLETDARKNESS
Renaissance Fantasy Fairy Off-Shoulder Chiffon Blouse
$45.99 SCARLETDARKNESS
GLAM AND GLORIA, LLC
Black Skeleton Thigh High Stockings
$9.90 GLAM AND GLORIA, LLC
CRONJAGER
Dark in Love Gothic Lace Square-Neck Puff Sleeve Dress
$39.99 CRONJAGER
ZAPAKA VINTAGE, INC.
Women's Shoes Mystery Box - 1 Surprise Pair (Heels, Boots & Sandals) -$19
$19.00 ZAPAKA VINTAGE, INC.
SCARLETDARKNESS
Fairycore Woodland Elf Ears
$11.99 SCARLETDARKNESS
CRONJAGER
Banned Apparel Elysia Dress
$42.00 CRONJAGER
CRONJAGER
Dark in Love Black Gothic Sweet Bow Lace Lolita Dress
$30.95 CRONJAGER
SCARLETDARKNESS
New Year Velvet Rose Earrings
$12.99 SCARLETDARKNESS
SCARLETDARKNESS
Gothic Witch Fishnet Socks
$15.99 SCARLETDARKNESS$50 to $1006 pieces

ZAPAKA VINTAGE, INC.
Black Leather Pointy Heels
$54.00 ZAPAKA VINTAGE, INC.
CRONJAGER
Want even more options?Dark in Love Lilith Bat Harness Bubble Dress
$55.00 CRONJAGER
201mary janes from 5 shops in the Fashion FinderSee them all →
CRONJAGER
Dark in Love Hexa Layered Tartan Effect Lace Skirt
$55.00 CRONJAGER
CRONJAGER
Dark in Love Vintage Striped Ruffle Tier Dress
$55.99 CRONJAGER
TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather T-Strap Buckle Square Toe High Block Heel Mary Janes Pumps Shoes - US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm / brown
$94.70 TINACUSTOM
TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Square Toe Mary Janes for Women with Double Straps - Black / US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm
$99.40 TINACUSTOMWorth the splurge6 pieces

TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Retro Hollow-Out Square Toe Mary Jane Flats Shoes - Pink / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
$104.70 TINACUSTOM
TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Buckle Strap Round Toe Mary Jane Flats Shoes - brown / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
$103.00 TINACUSTOM
TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Braided T-Strap Stacked Heel Pump Shoes - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
$104.00 TINACUSTOM
TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Women's Pointed Toe Genuine Leather Handmade Slip On Buckle Mid Chunky Heel Mary Janes Pumps - Black / US5/CN34/EU35/UK3/Foot Length-22cm
$102.40 TINACUSTOM
TINACUSTOM
TinaCus Handmade Women's Genuine Leather Round Toe Slip-on Chunky Heel Mary Jane Shoes with - Black / US4.5/CN33/EU34/UK2-2.5/Foot Length-21.5cm
$106.40 TINACUSTOM
TINACUSTOM











