The thing nobody tells you about a beige bag is that it takes a fingerprint of your life within about three weeks. Mine has gone slightly darker at the corner where my hand rests when I carry it, and there's a faint denim shadow along the bottom from where it sits against my jeans on the bus. It's not dirt exactly, more a record of use, and once you know that's coming you stop panicking about it.
I reach for a beige bag constantly from spring through early autumn, less so in the depths of winter when everything I own is wet from the knees down and a pale bag just records it all. It's brilliant against cream, navy, olive, denim, all the colours I actually wear, and it does a particular trick that black never manages, which is making an outfit look considered rather than just assembled. Where it falls short is anywhere with proper weather or proper mess involved. Festival mud, a dog that's just been in a river, a toddler with a biscuit, all of these end a beige bag's good run fairly fast. I learned this the hard way carrying one on a rainy platform where the hem of my coat kept flicking grit onto it, and by the time I got home it looked like it had been dragged there.
What separates a good one from a sad one is almost entirely in the leather, or whatever's standing in for it. A proper one has a bit of structure to the base so it holds its shape when it's half empty, and the colour sits in the material rather than sitting on top of it as a coating that scuffs white the first time it catches a doorframe. Cheap stitching gives itself away along the strap join first, puckering or pulling slightly after a few weeks of weight on one shoulder. Hardware matters more than you'd expect too, a zip that catches or a clasp that's already a bit loose in the shop will only get worse, never better.
For fit, think about where the bag actually sits rather than how it looks on a hook. A shoulder bag should sit at hip height without the strap digging into your collarbone, and if it gapes open at the top when you lean forward to pick something up, that's a sign the opening is too wide for how you'll use it day to day. Cross body styles need the strap long enough to sit properly across your body, not riding up under one arm by lunchtime, which is exactly what happened to the first one I bought and never fixed.
A good beige bag looks better the longer you've had it, which is more than I can say for most things in my cupboard.
If you want a different take, go for blue bags.