You can spot the good canvas bag from right across a room. The decent ones hang square, keep their shape even half empty, and the handles sit flat on the shoulder without curling up like they're trying to escape. The poor ones go baggy and lopsided within a fortnight, the bottom corners droop, and you end up carrying it like a sack of washing rather than a bag.
These work best doing the unglamorous jobs other bags sulk about. Thrown over a denim jacket, dumped on top of a buggy, taken to the shop for bits and the gym on the same afternoon. Mine goes with pretty much anything casual, jeans, a plain jumper, trainers, because it doesn't try to be the interesting part of the outfit. It just carries your stuff and gets on with it.
How they age depends entirely on the canvas weight, which you can feel with your hands before you've even paid. Thin canvas goes soft and papery fast, picks up marks from everything it touches, and the base goes grey within weeks. A heavier weave holds its shape, takes a proper scrub in the sink without falling apart, and actually looks better slightly worn in, a bit like good denim. Washing machines are a gamble, I'd always hand wash and air dry rather than risk the handles twisting or the print cracking.
They're not an all weather bag, canvas and heavy rain don't get on, so think of this as a dry season friend, spring through to early autumn, good for weekend markets, festivals, school runs, days where you need both hands free more than you need it to look smart. Come November it tends to sit in the cupboard until the sun's back.
Before you buy, check the stitching along the base and up the side seams, that's where the weight pulls first and where cheap ones give up. Press your thumb into the bottom panel, if there's no stiffening or reinforcement in there it'll bow out the second you load it with anything heavier than a paperback. Have a proper look at how the handles attach, riveted or boxed stitching lasts, a line of straight stitch through thin fabric does not. And check the inside for even one pocket, because canvas bags are notorious for turning into a lucky dip the moment your phone goes in with your keys.
A well made one is honestly one of the most useful bags you'll own, which makes it all the more annoying when a cheap one falls apart in a month.
I'd also keep clutch bags in mind.