The tell is always the edge closest to your thumb. Months in, that's the spot that goes pale first, where the dye rubs thin from being dragged out of a coat pocket fifty times a week. Shops never show you that bit, because it hasn't happened yet. It's also the bit that tells you, later, whether you bought well or just bought cheap and shiny.
If you don't own one yet, start plain. A slim holder with four or five slots and no zip, no fold, no extra flap for coins you'll never use. You want something that sits flat in a coat pocket without printing a card shaped bulge through your jeans. Anything with more compartments than you have cards is just extra bulk you'll carry around apologising for. The simple version also tells you fastest whether the thing is any good, because there's nowhere for bad construction to hide.
What separates the ones worth having from the ones you'll bin within a year comes down to three things: the leather, the stitching and what happens at the slot openings. Proper leather, even a thin one, keeps its shape and softens without collapsing. The coated stuff that looks identical on day one tends to crack along the fold line, usually right where your thumb opens it, and once it cracks it keeps going. Stitching should be tight and even, not loose enough that you can see daylight between threads, because that's where a card corner eventually pokes through. And the slot edges want to be bound or turned, not just a raw cut of material, otherwise they fray into little fuzzy bits that end up stuck to your debit card like static.
In the shop, do the obvious thing nobody does: put your own cards in before you buy it. See how tight the first slot is on day one, because tight now means impossible in six months once the leather's taken a set. Check the weight in your hand too, a holder that feels flimsy empty will feel worse full. For pairing it into normal life, the slim ones go straight into a coat pocket with nothing else, which is honestly the whole point of owning one rather than carrying a full purse to the corner shop. The slightly bigger ones, the sort with room for a note folded in half, work well tucked inside a tote alongside keys and lip balm, doing the one job without you having to think about it again.
If this is your sort of thing, you'll like purses too.