A good metallic bag catches the light without demanding it, the kind of bag that looks like brushed pewter until you move, and then it does something lovely. A poor one looks like it's been dipped in nail varnish, scuffs on the first wet pavement, and by the second month the metallic finish has worn off in patches, leaving a patchwork of coating and whatever dull fabric was hiding underneath. You can spot the difference across a room, and you can certainly spot it on the bus when someone's bag has gone the colour of a foil takeaway tray at the corners.
Pewter, gunmetal, a soft bronze or an old gold are the shades that behave themselves, because they read as neutral rather than as a statement, which means they sit quietly next to whatever you're already wearing instead of arguing with it. True silver can be sharp and a bit showroom under certain lights, and a loud gold can tip into fancy dress if the rest of the outfit isn't doing anything interesting. I was fairly sure I'd hate anything described as metallic on principle, bags included, having filed the whole category under things for parties that never happen. I'm annoyed to report a pewter one has outlasted several sensible black bags in my regular use.
The clever thing about a good metallic is that it does the job of a bold accessory while dressing like a neutral, so it goes with denim and a plain jumper just as happily as it goes with a dress, and it lifts an outfit that's entirely beige without you having to think about it. It sits well against navy, grey, black, camel, almost anything that isn't trying to be metallic itself, and that's really the only pairing rule worth remembering.
If you've none at all, start with a smaller bag in pewter or bronze rather than a bright silver clutch, because the quieter shade earns more wear across more days and doesn't look like it was bought for one specific evening.
How it ages depends entirely on what's under the shine. A genuine leather with a metallic finish will crease and soften a little, which looks like character. A coated synthetic will crack along the fold lines eventually, no matter how carefully you treat it, so keep it stuffed with tissue when it's not in use and out of direct heat, which is the only real care instruction that matters. A decent metallic bag is one of the few flashy ideas that actually behaves itself day to day.
It's worth comparing these with pink bags.