I clocked how useful these actually are at a leaving do in a packed function room, no cloakroom, nowhere to put a normal bag down without it ending up under someone's chair with the strap trodden on. Mine was across my body, flat against my hip, phone and card in it and nothing else, and I danced, ate, queued at the bar twice, and never once thought about where my bag was. That's the whole pitch, really. You stop managing it.
The difference between a good one and a bad one shows up fast, usually within a week. Cheap versions use a thin pleather that goes stiff and cracks along the fold lines, and the strap hardware is a nasty gold tone that scratches silver within days. A decent one has a strap that sits flat rather than twisting constantly, proper stitching at the stress points rather than glue, and a flap or zip that closes with a bit of resistance, not a flimsy magnetic snap that pops open if you lean the wrong way. The inside matters too. Look for a lining that doesn't fray the second a key goes in, and a card slot that actually holds the card rather than letting it slide out face down into your bag the first time you bend over. Weight tells you a lot before you even open it. A good one has a bit of heft and structure, even empty. The bad ones feel like a purse that's had delusions of grandeur.
If you've got none of these, start with a plain crossbody in a soft structured leather or a good faux, black or tan, with an adjustable strap long enough to wear across the body rather than just on the shoulder. Skip anything with excessive hardware or a novelty shape for your first one. You want it to disappear into whatever you're wearing, not compete with it.
These earn themselves properly in two very different situations: anything with movement, a wedding, a festival, a night where you're on your feet for hours, and the opposite end, a quick trip out where a full bag is overkill, the school run, a coffee, a walk round the shops on a Saturday. Spring and summer especially, when you're in lighter layers and a big bag just drags on one shoulder all day. The one mistake, and I've made it, is buying one so small your phone barely fits, then discovering you also need your card, your keys, and suddenly you're holding a second bag anyway, which rather defeats the point.
Adjustable strap bags are close cousins of these.