If you're stood there holding a silver bag and asking me straight out, I'd say put it on your arm, not just over your wrist, and walk to the far mirror, because silver is one of those finishes that either catches the light beautifully when you move or looks like it's wrapped in crisp packet foil, and you only find out which one by walking away and back. I had a bucket of silver brunia in the shop last week, tiny and metallic, sitting next to white ranunculus, and it only worked because the metal had a bit of grey in it rather than being pure chrome. Same rule applies here.
Before you hand over your money, run your thumb along the edges where the panels meet, because that's where a cheap one tells on itself first, a seam that's already starting to peel at the corner, a zip pull that feels light as a chocolate coin. Check the hardware isn't a bright, thin silver that'll go brassy looking within a season, you want something with a bit of weight and a slightly brushed finish, because that ages to pewter rather than to tarnish. Over months a good one softens at the creases and the metallic coating wears thin at the corners first, which looks lived in rather than knackered, and a bad one flakes in patches that look exactly like what they are. Wipe it down with a dry cloth now and again, keep it out of direct sun when you're not using it, and don't let it live crushed at the bottom of another bag, the coating doesn't love being folded against itself.
If you've none at all, start small, a clutch or a cross body rather than a big tote, because silver in a smaller size reads as a finish and in a huge size can read as a prop. It goes with more than people assume, a plain white shirt and jeans, a grey jumper, even navy, which I spent a decade wearing on its own and only now appreciate as the perfect quiet backdrop for a bit of shine.
The difference between the one you'll still carry in three years and the one that ends up at the back of the cupboard is almost always the base material under the metallic coating, a proper leather or a dense faux takes the finish evenly, a thin plasticky base goes patchy fast. I'd start with a soft pewter toned silver, somewhere between metal and grey, it goes with absolutely everything and never looks like it's trying.
I'd also check out mini bags.