I steered clear of woven bags for years, convinced they belonged to a holiday I wasn't on, all raffia and straw and the sort of bag that looks brilliant for one week in a hotel lobby and sad for the other fifty one. What changed my mind was borrowing one for a lunch I nearly didn't go to, and realising it carried everything I needed without looking like I was trying too hard.
If you're starting with one, go for a structured basket shape in a natural fibre, something with a flat base and a bit of body to it, rather than the soft slouchy ones that collapse the second you put a purse in. A simple round or boxy basket with short handles does more jobs than a trickier shape, and it sits well against most coats, which is more than I can say for half the bags I own.
The difference between a good one and a disappointing one is mostly in how tightly it's woven and what's holding it together. Cheap ones use a thin, dry straw that starts fraying at the rim within a month, and the handles are often just stapled or glued rather than stitched through the base, so they go first. A well made one uses a thicker, more pliable straw or raffia, woven close enough that you can't see daylight through it, with leather or fabric trim around the edges and handles that are properly reinforced where they meet the body of the bag. Run a finger along the rim in the shop. If it's already shedding, it will be worse after one wear.
These come into their own from late spring through early autumn, though I wear mine into a mild October without feeling like I've missed a seasonal memo. They're good for anything outdoorsy and slightly dressed up, a garden lunch, a weekend market, a wedding where the dress code says nothing but everyone's clearly gone for linen. I wouldn't reach for one in the rain, straw and wet pavements don't mix, and the structured ones in particular hate being left on a damp step. Mine lives on a hook, not the floor, after one bag swelled slightly at the base and never quite sat straight again.
The detail that makes a good one worth having is a proper inner lining with a zip pocket, because woven fabric has gaps a loose lipstick or set of keys will happily fall through. A bag that's thought about that, lined in cotton with a secure pocket, is the one you'll still be carrying happily in a few summers, unbothered and holding its shape.
Next stop, green bags.