The question I get asked most about heeled boots is whether they're actually comfortable enough to wear all day, and the honest answer is that it depends entirely on the heel height and the shape of the footbed, not the heel itself. A two inch block heel with a proper insole will see you through a full day on your feet. A four inch stiletto boot will not, no matter what the box promises.
These come into their own from early autumn right through to the start of spring, which is a long stretch of wear if you pick well. They're the thing that makes a plain dress look like you made an effort without actually trying harder, and they work just as well under trousers on a cold evening when trainers feel too flat and heels feel too much. I wear mine most on the days that start at a desk and end somewhere less sensible, because they do both without a change of shoes in a bag.
They pair with almost everything already hanging up, which sounds like a cop out but isn't, it's just true. A straight leg jean sits well over a low shaft boot, a midi skirt looks instantly more finished with one, and they're one of the few shoes that make opaque tights look deliberate rather than defensive. The one thing to watch is proportion, a wide calf boot under a skinny trouser can look odd, so try the combination before you commit to either piece.
If you're starting from nothing, go for a black ankle boot with a block heel between one and a half and two and a half inches, and leather or a good leather look rather than a shiny finish, which scuffs within a month and shows every mark after that. A proper boot should survive a winter of pavements, bus steps and the odd unexpected downpour without the heel wobbling or the sole lifting at the toe. Mine have been resoled once in three years and the leather has softened rather than cracked, which tells you the original was decent. Buy them a touch big rather than tight, because a boot that needs breaking in usually wins that argument with your feet, not the other way round.
The detail that makes a good pair a pleasure rather than a chore is a heel that sits slightly forward under the ball of the foot rather than dead centre under the heel bone, it throws your weight forward instead of back and you notice the difference somewhere around hour six, right when you'd otherwise be reaching for the flats in your bag.