For years I thought platform boots were a young person's trick, something to be worn once at twenty two and regretted in every photo since. What changed my mind was realising the platform does a job the heel can't, it tips you forward less, so you get height without the ten o'clock wobble on cobbles or stairs. That's the whole case for them, once you see it you can't unsee it.
Black is the one that never asks a question of the rest of your outfit, and a black leather or faux leather pair in a slightly worn, matte finish hides scuffs far better than anything patent or pale. Cream and tan look wonderful in the shop and show every drop of rain within a week, so unless you're prepared to polish them like a hobby, leave those to someone with a drier life than mine. They're at their best from October through to March, with thick tights or jeans, on days that involve a lot of standing and walking rather than sitting prettily at a table. A long coat and a platform boot is one of the few combinations that makes a short walk to the shops feel like it has somewhere to be. Where they fall apart as an idea is anywhere you need to move quickly, run for a bus, get down on the floor with a toddler, or navigate a narrow spiral staircase after a glass of wine, the sole doesn't flex the way a normal boot does, and that rigidity catches people out.
The honest test is what they look like after a winter rather than what they look like in the box. The platform sole is usually a separate piece of rubber or EVA glued to the leather upper, and that seam is where cheap ones fail first, mine split at the toe after about four months of proper wear, not because I'd done anything dramatic, just normal pavement and a lot of kerbs. A better made pair keeps that seam tight and the platform itself square rather than curling up at the edges, which is the first thing that goes and the first thing I now check before buying. They also pick up creasing across the ankle faster than a flat boot because of the angle your foot sits at, so if the leather feels stiff and shiny rather than soft in the shop, it will crack along that crease within a season, not after years. Try bending the boot at the ball of the foot before you buy it, if the platform doesn't give at all, your feet will know about it by the third wearing, and if it gives too easily, that's the seam that will go first.