The first pair of white boots I owned came from a market stall, pleather so stiff it creaked when I walked, and within a fortnight the toes had gone the colour of weak tea from nothing more dramatic than pavement dust. The lesson was simple: white shows everything, so the fabric and the finish matter more than the shape ever will.
These come into their own from late spring through early autumn, when the light is bright enough to carry them and the ground is dry enough that you're not asking white leather to survive a puddle. A pale ankle boot does something clever with a sundress or a slip skirt that black never manages, it lifts the whole outfit rather than grounding it, which makes it a good call for daytime weddings, long lunches, festival weekends, anything with a bit of occasion but no real formality. Where it struggles is deep winter and proper weather. Rain splashback, road salt, mud at a gig or a dog walk, all of it finds white boots and tells on you by lunchtime, so I keep mine for months when the forecast isn't actively plotting against me. They also clash harder than people expect with very cool toned outfits, icy blues, silvery greys, stark black and white combinations, the boot ends up looking like an afterthought rather than part of the plan. They sit far better against warmer palettes, tan, terracotta, olive, soft denim, where the white reads as a deliberate highlight instead of a mismatched leftover.
On finish, matte leather or a good suede alternative is far more forgiving day to day than anything glossy or patent, which scuffs if you so much as glance at a kerb and shows every mark under indoor lighting. An off white or bone shade hides general wear better than stark optic white too, and still gives you that lift without the maintenance headache of looking fresh out of the box every single time you leave the house.
Go a touch roomier than your usual size if the pair has any structure through the ankle, since white leather doesn't stretch or forgive the way a worn in black boot eventually does.