The moment it clicked for me was a work thing I almost didn't go to, thrown together in about four minutes: plain trousers, a plain top, and a cardigan buttoned up over the lot instead of a jacket I couldn't find. Someone asked where the outfit was from, and I had to explain that it was three boring things and one cardigan, and the cardigan was doing all of it. That's when I stopped treating them as the thing you put on when you're cold and started treating them as the thing that decides whether an outfit looks thought about.
They age well if you let them, which is the bit people skip. A good one gets softer and slightly looser at the elbows within a few wears, which is fine and even flattering, but if it starts dropping at the shoulder seam or the button band pulls into a gap over the chest, that's not it settling in, that's it being the wrong size and you knew that in the changing room really. Hand wash or a wool cycle on cold, lay it flat to dry, never hang a heavy knit on a hook unless you want sleeves two inches longer than you started with by December. A lint brush now and then. That's genuinely most of the care there is, and I say that as someone who has ruined exactly one on a hot wash and shrunk it into something that fit my niece and nobody else.
Where it earns its place is in how little it asks of the rest of you. Over a dress it covers the bit of arm you weren't sure about and sits at the hip in a way that stops a dress looking like loungewear. Over trousers and a plain top it's the whole outfit, the way mine was that day, especially if it's long enough to sit past the hip rather than stopping at the waist and adding a line you didn't want. With a shirt underneath, undone, collar out, it does something close to a blazer for half the effort and twice the comfort on a long day.
If you've got none, start with something mid weight, knee length or just above, in a colour that isn't black, because black ones vanish into everything and you'll forget you own it. A chunky going out one and a precise work one are both lovely eventually, but the first one should be the one you can wear to absolutely anything without thinking.
Would I still reach for this one in April, or is it only doing a job for the next six cold weeks?
Before you go, have a quick look at knitted cardigans.